
The case of Sanford Kaplan is a warning wrapped in a loophole: a man with a documented history of binding, blindfolding, and sexually abusing adolescent boys came within a court order of walking out of a Texas hospital with sole legal custody of a newborn, and the system built to prevent exactly that outcome caught the problem almost by accident.
The Short Version
- Sanford Kaplan, now 75, pleaded no contest in Nebraska in 2009 to seven counts of child abuse and one count of false imprisonment involving boys he held captive, admitting to sexual acts with as many as 18 victims.
- A Travis County, Texas court approved his surrogacy arrangement in August 2025, naming him the child’s legal father with a right to “immediate custody” at birth, without requiring a home study.
- A hospital’s own records check — not the surrogacy agency’s — surfaced Kaplan’s conviction days before the November 2025 birth, triggering emergency intervention by Texas child-protection authorities.
- A Texas jury terminated Kaplan’s parental rights in August 2026, finding his conduct endangered the child; he is now appealing that outcome.
- The case exposes a structural gap in American surrogacy law: no federal statute governs who may contract for a child, leaving background vetting to a patchwork of state courts, agencies, and private clinics that don’t always talk to each other.
What the Court Records Actually Show
In February 2025, Kaplan entered a surrogacy agreement with a young Texas woman, using his own sperm and a donor egg. Six months later, a Travis County court approved the arrangement in an order that reportedly designated Kaplan “the legal father” and granted him the right to immediate custody, naming authority, and medical decision-making power the moment the child was born. The court reached that conclusion while bypassing a home study — the standard vetting step meant to flag exactly the kind of history Kaplan had. That single procedural shortcut is where this case pivots from an ordinary custody dispute into a case study in institutional failure.
Kaplan’s record was not obscure. In 2009 he pleaded no contest to seven counts of child abuse and one count of false imprisonment in Nebraska, after an affidavit in which he admitted to “engaging in sexual acts” with adolescent boys he had held captive, suspended, and blindfolded. He served roughly 7.5 years of an eight-to-24-year sentence. None of that surfaced in time to stop the Texas court from approving his surrogacy contract — a fact that should unsettle anyone who assumes family courts cross-check criminal databases as a matter of course.
How the Arrangement Nearly Went Through
Surrogacy contracts in states like Texas can secure parentage before a child is even born, through what are called pre-birth or parentage orders. These instruments exist to spare intended parents the delay and uncertainty of a post-birth adoption process, and in the vast majority of arrangements they function exactly as designed — thousands of families use gestational surrogacy every year without incident. But the system’s efficiency depends entirely on the accuracy of what intended parents disclose. Kaplan’s own surrogacy attorney later told the court that Kaplan had “misrepresented his criminal history to myself and to the Court,” and a supporting affidavit attributed to Kaplan reportedly stated he had never been convicted of a felony or a crime involving moral turpitude — a claim directly contradicted by the Nebraska plea record. The surrogate herself told investigators Kaplan never disclosed his history to her either.
What makes the near-miss especially stark is who finally caught it. It wasn’t the surrogacy agency, which reportedly failed to turn up the conviction in its own search. It was the hospital where the birth was expected, running a routine public-records check shortly before delivery. That discovery reached Texas’s Department of Family and Protective Services in time for the agency to intervene, obtain emergency custody, and prevent Kaplan from leaving the hospital with the infant as the preliminary order had authorized.
The Reversal and the Jury’s Finding
A judge canceled the custody order the day before the baby’s birth in November 2025, and DFPS took emergency custody once the child arrived in Rockwall County. The agency’s removal affidavit went further than the original conviction record, alleging that Kaplan, when asked whether there were additional victims beyond those in his Nebraska case, estimated a total of 17 or 18. Nearly a year later, in August 2026, a Texas jury terminated Kaplan’s parental rights outright, concluding that his conduct endangered the child and that termination served the child’s best interest — a verdict that relied in part on the Nebraska convictions as evidence of ongoing risk. Kaplan is now appealing that termination, continuing to press his biological and contractual claim to the child even after a jury’s finding against him.
BREAKING
Single, 75-year-old convicted pedophile was granted parentage rights to a newborn boy through #surrogacy.
His previous offenses: "binding, blindfolding, gagging, and suspending boys from rafters in a garage at his Lincoln home while he was a youth soccer coach."
Only…
— Katy Faust (@Katy_Faust) November 18, 2026
Why a Case Like This Is Possible at All
American surrogacy law has no federal backbone. It is governed state by state, and the states diverge sharply — some enforce surrog













