
A public official who sets his own salary is, by definition, grading his own work—and Babylon, New York just supplied a textbook case of what happens when taxpayers notice.
Key Points
- Babylon Town Supervisor Rich Schaffer’s preliminary 2027 budget proposed raising his own salary 29.3%, from $123,680 to $160,000, alongside a near-6% property tax increase.
- Schaffer is simultaneously the Suffolk County Democratic Committee chairman and the subject of an FBI inquiry into alleged vote-buying, a fact residents raised repeatedly at the budget hearing.
- After sustained public criticism at a November hearing, Schaffer reversed course, telling Newsday “message received” and announcing a $3,700 pay cut instead of the raise.
- New York Town Law makes salary-setting a board function, and state comptroller opinions treat an elected official’s pay as an incident of the office itself—not a personal entitlement the officeholder can simply claim.
- The episode illustrates a structural flaw common to local government everywhere: the people who benefit from a raise are often the same people with the most control over whether it happens.
What the Budget Actually Proposed
The mechanics are not in dispute. When Babylon’s preliminary 2027 budget surfaced on October 15, it listed Supervisor Rich Schaffer’s salary at $160,000, up from $123,680—an increase of $36,320, or roughly 29.3%, that multiple outlets rounded to “30%” in headlines. The same budget proposed a property tax increase that different reports pegged at just under 6% and at 5.8%, depending on the line item measured. Schaffer told Newsday the Town Board would make the final call in January and that he personally would abstain from voting on his own raise—a procedural nicety that did little to blunt the optics of a sitting supervisor’s name appearing, unprompted, at the top of a pay-raise line in his own administration’s budget document.
Town of Babylon Resolution No. 37, dated January 5, 2026, had already fixed Schaffer’s salary at $123,679 for that year—the baseline against which the proposed jump was measured. That resolution is the kind of routine municipal paperwork that almost never makes news. This one did, because it arrived folded into a budget cycle shadowed by a federal investigation.
The FBI Inquiry Changed the Political Weather
Schaffer is not an ordinary town supervisor. He has also chaired the Suffolk County Democratic Committee, giving him outsized influence over Long Island politics well beyond Babylon’s borders, and he is currently under FBI scrutiny tied to allegations of vote-buying. That overlapping status—elected official, party boss, subject of a federal probe—gave the salary dispute a charge that an ordinary cost-of-living adjustment would never generate. At the public hearing, Copiague resident Jackie Burbridge put the connection directly to Schaffer: “We are being asked to pay for a 29% salary increase for you as you are actively being investigated by the federal and state for corruption charges”. Another resident asked bluntly whether the proposed tax increase was meant to cover his legal fees. Those are pointed, named, on-the-record objections, not vague unease—and they go to the heart of why this particular raise, of all the raises proposed in town halls across the country every budget season, became a flashpoint.
How Residents Forced a Reversal
More than three dozen speakers turned out to challenge the budget, a remarkable showing for a town board hearing. Karen Scribner’s complaint—”I just don’t understand how someone can give themselves a 29% raise”—captured the plain-spoken incredulity that dominated the evening. Deer Park’s Joseph Prevete asked how officials could justify the increase “when things are so, everybody’s so strapped for cash”, while his neighbor Kristin Schuster argued that Babylon’s habit of exceeding New York’s property-tax cap was supposed to be an occasional emergency measure, not a routine budgeting tool. The breadth of the backlash—spanning Babylon proper, Copiague, and Deer Park—suggests this was not a single aggrieved constituency but a town-wide reaction to the arithmetic: a nearly 6% tax increase landing on households at the same moment their supervisor proposed a 29% raise for himself.
The board listened. By November 12, Schaffer told Newsday he would not accept the increase and would instead take a $3,700 pay cut, reducing his salary to roughly $120,000; other proposed raises for elected officials were stripped from the budget entirely. “I’m serious about the challenges we face, so I cut my salary for next year,” he said. On social media, Newsday reported his more candid summary of the episode: “Message received”. That is a rare, unambiguous concession in local politics—an official reading a hearing room correctly and reversing a documented, published budget line within weeks.
Babylon Town Supervisor Rich Schaffer says he will take a pay cut instead of a proposed 29% raise following backlash from residents.
Schaffer’s salary was set to increase from $123,680 to $160,000 under the proposed 2027 budget. He now says he will reduce his salary to $120,000.… pic.twitter.com/2cJisGTZwx
— Newsday (@Newsday) November 13, 2026
Why This Keeps Happening Everywhere
Babylon’s dispute is a vivid local instance of a chronic structural problem in American municipal government: elected bodies typically set their own compensation, or that of their close colleagues, creating an obvious conflict of interest. Scholarship on city and town council pay identifies two failure modes that pull in opposite directions—self-dealing that inflates salaries when oversight is weak, and “reverse ratcheting,” where officials keep pay artificially low out of fear of voter backlash, discouraging capable people from running for office at all. New York’s Town Law § 27 assigns salary authority to the town board as a body, and the state comptroller has long held that an elected officer’s salary is “an incident of the office,” not a personal claim tied to the individual who happens to hold it—a legal distinction that exists precisely because lawmakers have never fully trusted officeholders to police their own paychecks. Babylon’s residents, whether or not they could cite the statute, understood the principle instinctively and showed up to enforce it the only way citizens reliably can: in person, at the microphone, before the vote.
Sources:
nypost.com, us.headtopics.com, townofbabylonny.gov, newsday.com, ilovebabylon.com, hudsonvalley.news12.com













